“What McAvoy did next can only be described as ‘assault.'” This statement encapsulates the controversy surrounding Charlie McAvoy after his violent retaliation during Game 6 against the Buffalo Sabres on May 1, 2026, in Buffalo, NY. The incident has raised significant concerns regarding player safety and disciplinary measures in the NHL.
McAvoy received a game misconduct after retaliating to a slew-foot from Zach Benson with a baseball swing slash. The incident occurred during the final minutes of the game, which the Sabres won to clinch the series. Benson was penalized for his dangerous play, receiving a two-minute penalty for the slew-foot.
The game’s score was 4-1 when McAvoy was ejected for slashing. His actions have drawn criticism, with some commentators stating, “That kind of swing would get you 5-10 in a state penitentiary if you tried it on the streets.” Public opinion seems split on the matter, reflecting differing views on player conduct in playoff hockey.
This incident is particularly notable as McAvoy has dealt with injuries this season, including a broken jaw and lost teeth. A slew foot is regarded as a dangerous play within the sport, and such actions can lead to serious consequences for players.
If McAvoy faces suspension from the NHL Player Safety department, he would serve it next season. This potential ruling will be closely watched by fans and analysts alike.